Can Information from China Be Trusted?

The number of confirmed cases of coronavirus (2019-nCoV) has reached 9,776, with 213 deaths, according to the interactive map provided by Johns Hopkins CSSE (Center for Systems Science and Engineering).

But is it plausible that China has locked down 17 cities because of 213 deaths?

A Jan 28 directive issued by China’s Ministry of Public Security ordered all police departments throughout the country to make “wartime preparations.” The police are to help “control the disease” by enforcing quarantine orders and helping to speed the distribution of medical supplies, while at the same time “maintaining social stability” by “severely” punishing any public or online reporting about the spread of the epidemic.

A Twitter post read: “The [Wuhan] city government and Hubei Provincial Civil Affairs Ministry have dispatched vehicles, staff, and protective gear to each funeral house [in Wuhan].” The post went on to offer “free cremation for the corpses of coronavirus victims” who died on January 26 or later. The reason the city was deploying these new resources, it said, was “To improve the capacity of transporting and dealing with corpses.”

The post obviously didn’t please the censors, writes Steven Mosher. An hour later the above sentences were deleted from the text.

Crematorium workers in the city of Wuhan claim that bodies are being sent from hospitals without being added to the official record.

The first wave of cases must have occurred in December or earlier because by Jan 2, 41 cases admitted to hospital in Wuhan had a laboratory-confirmed diagnosis of 2010-nCoV. But Wuhan was not placed under quarantine until 5 million people had left to celebrate the New Year, carrying the virus all across China.

Before the 1918 influenza epidemic, a solo, horse-and-buggy physician in Kansas, Dr. Loring Miner, made the correct diagnosis of an unusually lethal outbreak of influenza and did all he could to sound the alarm. The U.S. Public Health Service ignored him, writes John M. Barry in his 2004 book, The Great Influenza: the Epic Story of the Deadliest Plague in History. Might social media have stopped that epidemic in its tracks?

China’s Great Firewall is the most sophisticated internet censorship operation in the world. Google’s secret Project Nightingale to facilitate the Chinese dictatorship’s censorship has apparently been stymied for now. However, U.S. providers of online services have yielded to pressure from Rep. Adam Schiff to suppress material he deems inappropriate for the public access. At the moment, this is restricted to information on vaccine adverse reactions. The suppression of free speech and public access to government-disfavored views is the subject of a lawsuit by the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS).

The 2019-nCoV may be unstoppable in China by now. Protecting the rest of the world requires vigilance and free communication.

For further information, with links to information on protecting yourself and your family, see Doctors for Disaster Preparedness Newsletter, September 2019.

Coronavirus Has International Impact

The World Health Organization (WHO) is meeting to decide whether to declare the 2019-nCoV a Public Health Emergency of International Concern (PHEIC).

An interactive map shows the progress of the disease: 7,783 confirmed cases at this moment, and 170 deaths. Since diagnostic test kits are not widely available, the number of actual cases is unknown.

Also still unknown: how easily is the virus transmitted, can it be transmitted by a person who has no symptoms or fever, and what is the mortality rate? So, should we be more or less worried than we are about the usual seasonal influenza, which has reportedly caused 8,200 deaths and 140,000 hospitalizations so far this year?

Even if public health authorities in both China and the U.S. are being completely transparent, projections could be massively wrong if the virus mutates to become more or less lethal or transmissible.

Two things are certain:

(1) The U.S. is not prepared to cope with a 1918-scale epidemic and urgently needs to remedy the lack of surge capacity for medical facilities, personnel, and supplies. Citizens need to have an insurance policy: supplies they need to self-isolate at home, and knowledge to care for a sick family member. See Three Seconds until Midnight by Dr. Steven Hatfill, et al., and its on-line self-help sources (here and here).

(2) The economic consequences will be vast. With 17 Chinese cities already locked down and further restrictions likely, factories are likely to face worker shortages or extended shutdowns. The supply of essential drugs in the U.S. and elsewhere is critically dependent on China—for finished products or precursors, as Rosemary Gibson points out in her book China Rx. The U.S. cannot even make penicillin. Other industries vulnerable to disruptions in the supply chain are defense, computers especially Apple, automobile manufacturers, and suppliers of masks and other protective medical equipment.

For further information, see Doctors for Disaster Preparedness Newsletter, September 2019.

Unknowns about Coronavirus

Is a deadly pandemic about to hit us, or is the biggest quarantine effort in human history, locking down many cities in China, an overreaction?

There are now five confirmed cases of coronavirus in the U.S., all associated with travel to China, and about 100 more are under investigation. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) is at present the only source for diagnostic testing.

Where did the novel virus, called 2019-nCoV, come from? Reportedly, the source was the Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market in Wuhan, China, which also offers exotic fresh meat, some from live animals. A bat or other animal virus may have mutated and crossed the species barrier to humans. However, according to a study of 41 patients hospitalized in Wuhan, published in The Lancet, 13 of the 41 had no link to the market, which was closed Jan 1. Human-to-human transmission is surely occurring.

There is speculation that the virus might have been accidentally released from the Wuhan Institute of Virology, located 20 miles from the seafood market. The laboratory is the only declared site in China capable of working with deadly viruses. China is suspected to have a covert biological warfare program.

Recall that in 1979 an outbreak of anthrax in the Soviet Union, originally attributed to tainted meat, was eventually shown to have originated from a biowarfare facility at Sverdlovsk.

Whether bioengineered by nature or by scientists, novel microorganisms for which there is no immunity and no treatment could kill hundreds of millions of humans if not contained.

Virologists and epidemiologists are racing to answer basic questions. How contagious is 2019-nCoV? Can it be transmitted by people who have no fever and no symptoms—and for how long? What is the mortality rate?

Previous threats, such as SARS (severe acute respiratory syndrome) and Ebola, have been contained. But despite these wake-up calls, the U.S. is no better prepared for a lethal pandemic than it was for the great influenza in 1918, according to Dr. Steven Hatfill and coauthors in their new book Three Seconds until Midnight. We lack adequate stockpiles of protective gear, surge capacity in medical facilities and personnel, preparedness to maintain essential infrastructure, and efficient distribution mechanisms for vaccines or drugs if they exist.

Also essential is accurate, timely, uncensored information. A big unknown is the reliability of information on the internet or from government, especially in closed societies such as China. Citizens need to practice meticulous hygiene and avoid sources of exposure.

For further information, see Doctors for Disaster Preparedness Newsletter, September 2019, and self-help sources recommended in Three Seconds until Midnight by Steven Hatfill, M.D., et al.

What Is the Corona Virus Doing Now?

By the time you read a report it may be outdated. But the most current U.S. government information is at CDC.gov. So far, the Chinese Lunar New Year shares top billing with smoking, seasonal influenza, and raw milk, and the outlook is generally reassuring. Most importantly, the site tells how to contact officials to get reliable diagnostic testing.

Remember that governments have a history of covering up infectious disease dangers, as in the 1918 influenza pandemic, or of exaggerating, as in swine flu scares of 1976 and 2009, and the post-9/11 anthrax panic. Widespread self-isolation is bad for the economy. Or there may be special interests profiting from sales of poorly tested, dangerous vaccines or drugs.

What should the prudent citizen do? “Everyone should have an all-hazards preparedness plan as an insurance policy,” advises Physicians for Civil Defense president Jane M. Orient, M.D. “Many disasters call for shelter-in-place. Do you have what you need to stay home for a couple of weeks?”

“You do not want to be caught in a stampede to obtain food, medicines, or other essentials.”

In case of an epidemic, hospitals will be swamped—with patients who are likely contagious. It may be advisable or necessary to care for sick patients at home. Do you have disposable gloves, masks, batteries, tissues, vitamin C, hand sanitizer, bleach and other disinfecting and cleaning supplies, trash bags, and self-help medical information? Dr. Orient asks.

News from China suggests the time is late:

  • The People’s Liberation Army sent 450 medical personnel to Wuhan to help out at local hospitals, which are crammed with patients lying in packed corridors.
  • Chinese travel restrictions have grown to encompass more than 50 million people.
  • Frightening videos are being taken down.
  • Construction workers are reportedly trying to build a 1,000-bed hospital in five days.

For further information, see Doctors for Disaster Preparedness Newsletter, September 2019, and self-help sources recommended in Three Seconds until Midnight by Steven Hatfill, M.D., et al.

Coronavirus Pandemic Possible, Warns Physicians for Civil Defense

For the first time since 1949, outbound transportation from a provincial capital in China is being shut down, in response to an outbreak of a novel coronavirus infection, reports the Washington Post, in the middle of the busiest travel season of the year. About 400 million people are expected to be in transit before Lunar New Year’s Day.

Human-to-human transmission of this animal virus has now been reported.  “Species jumping of zoonotic (animal) diseases is a constant threat, especially when humans live close to animals,” stated Physicians for Civil Defense president Jane M. Orient, M.D. “Mutations and mixing and matching in genetic material of viral strains can produce highly transmissible, lethal strains to which humans have no immunity.”

The report of 800 cases in China, centered in the city of Wuhan, is believed to be a gross underestimate, and a  few cases have been reported in Taiwan, Thailand, Japan, South Korea, and the U.S., Dr. Orient stated.

At a Wuhan hospital, staff members are reportedly not being allowed to resign or leave the city.

Symptoms include fever, fatigue, and difficulty breathing. Patients may get a severe pneumonia.

The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)—which on Tuesday activated its Emergency Response System—said it had been preparing for the possibility of 2019-nCoV entering the U.S. “for weeks.”

The CDC claims to have made great strides in preparedness since the SARS (Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome) crisis in 2003. Yet despite spending $80 billion on a National Biologic Defense, the U.S. is arguably no better prepared than it was in 1918, when the great influenza pandemic killed more people than the Black Death, according to Steven Hatfill, M.D., and coauthors in their new book Three Seconds until Midnight.

Vaccine and effective antiviral drugs are lacking, and in an epidemic non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPI) would be key. These include eye protection, N-95 masks, hand sanitizers, and disinfection of surfaces, where infective virus can persist for days, when caring for a  sick person, Dr. Orient noted.

Individuals and local authorities must be alert and prepared and not depend on a timely federal response, Dr. Orient stated.

Physicians for Civil Defense distributes information to help to save lives in the event of war or other disaster.

Nuclear Forces Mobilized in Wake of Soleimani’s Death, States Physicians for Civil Defense

According to a report that the Pentagon declines to comment on, six nuclear-capable B-52 bombers have been deployed to Diego Garcia, a British-owned island base in the Indian Ocean. This is beyond the current range of Iranian ballistic missiles.

“Missiles launched from Iran are of course not the only threat in today’s tense world,” comments Jane M. Orient, M.D., president of Physicians for Civil Defense. “General Qassem Soleimani, who was killed by a U.S. drone strike, was reportedly involved in planning terrorist strikes. His death does not end those threats.”

According to an October 2019 report by the Congressional Research Service (CRS), Iran has cultivated relationships with drug-smuggling cartels and has sought to place Quds Force (Iranian-backed terrorist) operatives in Latin America. Americans need to be aware of threats from south of an unsecured border or from sleeper cells, warns Chris Farrell of Judicial Watch.

Continue reading “Nuclear Forces Mobilized in Wake of Soleimani’s Death, States Physicians for Civil Defense”

Iranian General Dead, What’s Next, Asks Physicians for Civil Defense

After Iranian General Qassem Soleimani was killed by a U.S. drone strike, Iran has vowed reprisals. A senior commander of Iran’s powerful Revolutionary Guards Corps claims that up to 35 “vital” US and Israeli targets are within Iran’s reach.

Physicians for Civil Defense observes that in this age of “asymmetric warfare,” civilians here, not just military installations “over there,” are at risk.

Iran’s aspirations of being a nuclear power, with ballistic missiles capable of delivering nuclear warheads to America, have apparently not yet been achieved, but other methods of causing mass casualties and disruptions are available, states Jane M. Orient, M.D, president of Physicians for Civil Defense.

Continue reading “Iranian General Dead, What’s Next, Asks Physicians for Civil Defense”