CIVIL DEFENSE PERSPECTIVES
January 1996 (vol. 12, #2) 1601 N Tucson Blvd #9, Tucson AZ 85716 c 1996 Physicians for Civil Defense
SOVEREIGNTY
Throughout history, the cause of war has been the struggle for sovereignty. The preservation of sovereignty is today a strong motive for possessing weapons of mass destruction.
One authority on the subject is Saddam Hussein, who, of course, retains his power in Iraq. A document newly available from the US Dept. of Defense, a mid-1990 report from a special Interagency Intelligence Community working group on Iraqi CBW capability, stated that Iraq had weaponized anthrax, botulinum toxin, and Clostridium perfringens (the causative agent of gas gangrene). The agents were being produced in four facilities, and a state-of-the-art back-up plant, disguised as an infant-formula factory, was also ready to begin production. Biological weapons were stored across the country, in 35 refrigerated bunkers.
``Iraq would consider using BW as a weapon to save the regime from falling,'' the report stated (CWCB #30, Dec 1995).
Rolf Ekéus, UNSCOM Executive Chairman, after receiving Iraq's ``full, final and complete disclosure'' of its BW program, told reporters that the report was incomplete. There was still no accounting for some 20% of the bacterial growth media imported by Iraq, and no convincing evidence that the BW agents said to have been produced were indeed destroyed. In a later (September) report, he reported previously undisclosed flight tests of Scud missiles carrying chemical warheads.
Saad Salih Jabr, the Shi'ite leader of the London-based Free Iraq Council, told Israeli television viewers that Iraq stored hundreds of CBW warheads in underground desert caches, along with at least 32 Scud missiles. ``He says that the hidden weapons represent a last resort of Saddam Hussein, who, once he knows his regime is doomed, will order their use against Israel in order to instigate a major Iraqi-Israeli confrontation'' (Israel TV Channel 1, Aug 18 in BBC-SWB Aug 21, ibid.)
It was further reported to the UN that ``authority to launch biological and chemical warheads was pre-delegated in the event that Baghdad was hit by nuclear weapons during the Gulf War.''
Former President George Bush probably had better reasons than most Americans know for leaving Hussein in power.
The UN program to discover and destroy Iraq's CBW capability has cost about $100 million so far. According to Madeleine Albright, US representative to the UN, it would take less than a year to rebuild the BW program.
Another nation recently accused of employing CBW to assert its sovereignty is Russia. Chechens claim that, in addition to standard military firepower, Russian chemical weapons have been dropped on civilians from aircraft. Col Gen Stanislav Petrov, commander of Russian RKhB Protection Troops, claimed that ``it is simply blasphemous to say that the Russian army or the Russian Internal Troops are using chemical weapons'' (CWCB #30). Petrov noted, however, that a map showing the location of Russian CW sites had been published by ``environmental groups.'' General Mikhail Kolesnikov, Chief of the General Staff of the Russian Armed Forces, casts doubts on the country's ability to destroy its stockpile of CW and speaks of increasing vulnerability to theft.
Chemical and biological weapons are also very effective for destroying the sovereignty of another nation.
As Israel's new Prime Minister Shimon Peres pushes toward a deal with Syria over the Golan Heights, an Israel-US defense pact has been suggested. The idea would be to compensate Israel for the loss of the Golan Heights by defining an attack on Israel as an attack on the United States.
``In the event of war [such a pact] will in all probability not be worth the paper it is printed on,'' is the assessment of Intelligence Digest (Stoneyhill Centre, Brimpsfield, Gloucester, GL4 8LF, UK, Dec 15-29, 1995).
``What American administration would order a highly risky military operation to restore an already-defeated Israel...if a likely consequence would be major civilian casualties throughout America?'' The idea of planting a nuclear, chemical, or biological device in American cities to deter American intervention is no longer science fiction. Lisa Gordonson-Hagerty, head of the Nuclear Emergency Search Team (NEST), in an unprecedented public statement, said that she now thinks about nuclear terrorism ``more in terms of when, not if'' (ID, 1/5/96).
The existence of enormous stockpiles of CBW throughout the world has previously been referred to in this newsletter. Still another was reported last summer in China Youth Daily, which stated that China needs more than $1 billion to dispose of chemical weapons abandoned by the Imperial Japanese Army at the end of World War II. More than 1.8 million weapons have been buried in deep pits, and another 200,000 reportedly remain in storage depots.
There is ample precedent for use of such weapons, hidden from public scrutiny for nearly 50 years. Reports of a strategic biological warfare network that existed across China and Southeast Asia during World War II are now coming to light. It is believed that more than 10,000 Chinese, Dutch, Korean, Mongolian, and US prisoners were killed by Japanese unit 731. A campaign in 20 Chinese provinces is said to have killed hundreds of thousands of Chinese civilians. Campaigns were also planned for the Philippines, Australia, Burma, Guam, Hawaii, and elsewhere, but not carried out (CWCB #30).
Weapons of mass destruction can also deny the benefits of sovereignty to an enemy through residual effects. Biological or radioactive contamination are obvious examples. But another, still cheaper item is the land mine, called by some a weapon of mass destruction because of its overall impact, even though it takes one life (or hand or foot) at a time.
There are believed to be more than 100 million mines scattered in 64 countries, including Cambodia, Angola, and Mozambique, with about 6 million in Bosnia alone. Four million Afghan refugees in Pakistan and Iran can't go home because the mines are still there, even though the Soviets who laid them are now gone. Like BW, mines are a poor man's weapon. They cost about $3 per copy to manufacture, and about $3,000 each to immobilize.
The advent of low-cost weapons of mass destruction transforms the dynamics of world affairs and makes the term ``Superpower'' obsolete.
But then our nuclear arsenal never was the ``Power that hath made and preserves us a nation.'' A successful defense of our sovereignty must be based on right, not on brute force.